→ Home / Mattresses / Comparison
Best Mattress For New Homes 2024
Join the countless satisfied shoppers who turn to Top5product.com to make smart purchase decisions. Our experts personally tested and compared countless top-rated mattresses, and combed through research, reviews, and pricing to bring you our recommendations.
Last Updated Sep 2024
Rank #1
★★★★★
- Luxury Hybrid Design: Combines plush memory foam with supportive innerspring coils for ideal comfort.
- Eco-Friendly Materials: Crafted with organic cotton, eco-friendly foam, and recycled steel coils.
- Three Firmness Options: Available in Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm for personalized comfort.
- Advanced Lumbar Support: Extra back support for spinal alignment and pressure relief.
- Edge Reinforcement: Dual perimeter edge support for better stability and increased sleep surface.
- Cooling Technology: Breathable organic cotton and dual coil system keep you cool all night.
- No Off-Gassing: Made without harmful chemicals, offering a fresh, odor-free sleeping experience.
- CertiPUR-US® Certified: Safe from harmful chemicals, ensuring a healthier sleep environment.
- Handcrafted in the USA: Quality craftsmanship for enhanced durability and comfort.
- 15-Year Warranty: Comes with a 15-year warranty and free in-home setup with mattress removal.
- Comfort & Support 98%
- Durability 100%
- Cooling & Breathability 100%
- Customization Options 100%
- Value For Money 98%
Labor Day Deals!
Save Up To $600
Rank #2
★★★★★
- Cloud-Like Comfort: Soft memory foam hugs your body for pressure relief and ultimate comfort.
- Cooling Technology: Cooling Cloud foam keeps you cool all night by dispersing heat.
- All-Season Adaptability: Designed to adjust to any climate, ensuring year-round comfort.
- Body-Conforming Support: Provides balanced support for pressure relief and spinal alignment.
- Motion Isolation: Ideal for couples—no more sleep disruptions from movement.
- Hypoallergenic: Resists dust mites and allergens for a healthier sleep environment.
- Stain-Resistant Cover: Washable and stain-resistant cover keeps the mattress fresh.
- Safe & Certified: CertiPUR-US® certified for non-toxic, eco-friendly materials.
- Lifetime Warranty: Backed by a lifetime warranty for peace of mind.
- 101-Night Trial: Try it risk-free with a 101-night sleep trial.
- Comfort & Support 95%
- Durability 100%
- Cooling & Breathability 95%
- Customization Options 95%
- Value For Money 95%
Rank #3
★★★★★
- Air-Engineered™ Comfort: Designed to improve airflow and deliver optimal pressure relief for a cool, comfortable sleep.
- Cooling Technology: Uses advanced cooling gel foam to regulate temperature and prevent overheating.
- Recovery-Focused: Developed for athletes, it promotes better recovery by providing muscle support and spinal alignment.
- Responsive Support: Adapts to your body movements, ensuring consistent support in any sleep position.
- Open-Cell Construction: Breathable materials allow heat and moisture to escape, keeping you cool and dry.
- Motion Isolation: Minimizes motion transfer, ensuring undisturbed sleep, even with movement.
- Hypoallergenic Materials: Made from eco-friendly, hypoallergenic foam, safe for sensitive sleepers.
- CertiPUR-US® Certified: Free of harmful chemicals, ensuring a healthy sleep environment.
- Lifetime Warranty: Backed by a lifetime warranty for long-lasting peace of mind.
- 100-Night Trial: Offers a risk-free 100-night sleep trial to ensure it’s the perfect fit for you.
- Comfort & Support 90%
- Durability 95%
- Cooling & Breathability 90%
- Customization Options 100%
- Value For Money 92%
Rank #4
★★★★★
- Organic Materials: Made with certified organic cotton, wool, and natural latex for an eco-friendly and sustainable sleep experience.
- No Chemicals or Toxins: Free from harsh chemicals, flame retardants, and polyurethane foams, making it safe for sensitive sleepers.
- Handcrafted Quality: Each mattress is handmade in the USA with high-quality materials for durability and longevity.
- Supportive Design: Features pocketed coils for support and alignment, reducing pressure points and promoting better spinal health.
- Breathable Construction: Natural latex and wool provide excellent airflow, helping regulate temperature throughout the night.
- Firm & Balanced Feel: Offers a balanced firmness ideal for back and stomach sleepers, with gentle cushioning for comfort.
- Sustainable Production: Avocado is committed to ethical practices, including fair trade certifications and environmentally friendly production.
- 25-Year Warranty: Comes with a 25-year warranty, ensuring long-term quality and support.
- Comfort & Support 80%
- Durability 85%
- Cooling & Breathability 80%
- Customization Options 80%
- Value For Money 82%
Rank #5
★★★★★
- Eco-Friendly Materials: Made with natural, sustainable materials like organic cotton, wool, and plant-based memory foam.
- Greenguard Gold Certified: Meets strict health and safety standards, ensuring low chemical emissions for a healthier sleep environment.
- Pressure-Relieving Foam: Features contouring memory foam that reduces pressure points and provides support for joints and muscles.
- Cooling Gel Layer: Includes a cooling gel-infused foam layer that helps regulate body temperature and prevent overheating.
- Zoned Support: Designed with zoned coils that offer targeted support, improving spinal alignment and reducing motion transfer.
- Handcrafted in the USA: Assembled with care using quality materials to ensure lasting durability and comfort.
- Ethically Produced: Brentwood is committed to sustainable practices, using renewable resources and responsible manufacturing processes.
- 25-Year Warranty: Backed by a 25-year warranty, offering peace of mind for long-term use.
- Comfort & Support 80%
- Durability 75%
- Cooling & Breathability 70%
- Customization Options 65%
- Value For Money 75%
Our Top Choice For 2024
The Saatva mattress is where luxury meets eco-consciousness. Designed for those who crave premium comfort and top-tier support, this hybrid mattress blends the plushness of memory foam with the durability of innerspring coils. It's available in three firmness levels—Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm—catering to every sleeper, whether you love sinking into softness or prefer firm support. Handcrafted in the USA with sustainable materials, Saatva delivers both comfort and peace of mind, perfect for those who want a healthy, restful sleep experience.
Key Features
✔ Luxury Hybrid Design: Combines memory foam’s cozy comfort with innerspring coils’ robust support for a balanced, luxurious sleep.
✔ Customizable Firmness: Choose from three firmness levels to match your preferred sleep style, whether you're a side, back, or stomach sleeper.
✔ Eco-Friendly Materials: Made from organic cotton, eco-friendly foams, and recycled steel coils, ensuring a sustainable and safe sleep environment.
✔ Advanced Lumbar Support: Features an active wire support system for enhanced spinal alignment and a memory foam layer to ease pressure points.
✔ Cooling Technology: Breathable organic cotton cover and dual coil system promote airflow to keep you cool all night long.
✔ Edge Support: Reinforced edges provide stability, so you can sleep or sit near the edge without sinking or rolling off.
✔ Handcrafted in the USA: Each mattress is meticulously handcrafted with premium materials for exceptional quality and durability.
✔ CertiPUR-US® Certified: Made without harmful chemicals, ensuring a non-toxic sleep experience for even the most sensitive sleepers.
✔ Free White Glove Delivery: Includes in-home setup and old mattress removal at no extra charge, adding to the luxury experience.
✔ 15-Year Warranty: Backed by a 15-year warranty with free repairs or replacements within the first two years.
Final Verdict
The Saatva mattress is an exceptional blend of luxury, comfort, and eco-friendliness. It’s perfect for sleepers who want to invest in their health and well-being, thanks to its customizable firmness, advanced lumbar support, and cooling features. While the price may be higher, the long-lasting comfort and premium materials make it well worth the investment. If you’re seeking a top-quality mattress that delivers on both luxury and sustainability, Saatva is a standout choice.
Labor Day Deals!
Save Up To $600
Factors to Consider While Buying a Mattress
When buying a mattress, there are several key factors to consider to ensure you select the right one for your needs. Here’s a comprehensive guide on what to look for:
Type of Mattress
- Innerspring: Traditional mattresses with coils; good for support and bounce.
- Memory Foam: Conforms to your body; excellent for pressure relief and motion isolation.
- Latex: Responsive and durable; offers natural cooling and support.
- Hybrid: Combines coils and foam/latex for a balance of support and comfort.
- Airbed: Adjustable firmness with air chambers; customizable to individual preferences.
Firmness Level
- Soft: Ideal for side sleepers who need pressure relief.
- Medium: A balanced option suitable for various sleeping positions.
- Firm: Better for back and stomach sleepers who need extra support.
- Adjustable: Some mattresses allow you to adjust firmness levels.
Material Quality
- Comfort Layers: Look for high-quality foam, latex, or cushioning materials.
- Support Core: Ensure it has durable and supportive components like coils or high-density foam.
- Cover: Breathable and durable fabric, such as organic cotton or bamboo.
Support
- Spinal Alignment: The mattress should keep your spine in a neutral position.
- Pressure Relief: It should relieve pressure points, particularly in the shoulders, hips, and knees.
- Edge Support: Strong edges prevent sagging and offer better support when sitting on the edge.
Temperature Regulation
- Cooling Features: Look for materials like gel-infused foam or breathable covers if you tend to sleep hot.
- Breathability: Ensure the mattress allows for proper airflow to regulate temperature.
Durability
- Material Quality: Higher quality materials generally mean a longer-lasting mattress.
- Warranty: A longer warranty period can be a good indicator of durability and manufacturer confidence.
Motion Isolation
- Individual Movement: Memory foam and some hybrids are good at isolating motion, making them ideal for couples.
Trial Period and Return Policy
- Trial Period: A longer trial period allows you to test the mattress in your own home.
- Return Policy: Check the ease of returning or exchanging the mattress if it doesn’t work out.
Price
- Budget: Determine your budget and look for a mattress that offers the best value within that range.
- Cost vs. Quality: Balance cost with material quality and features to ensure you're getting a good deal.
Certifications
- CertiPUR-US: Indicates foam is made without harmful chemicals.
- OEKO-TEX: Ensures materials are free from harmful substances.
- GOTS: For organic cotton and other materials, indicating they meet organic standards.
Brand Reputation and Reviews
- Reviews: Read customer reviews to gauge satisfaction and performance.
- Brand Reputation: Consider brands known for quality and customer service.
Size and Compatibility
- Size: Ensure the mattress fits your bed frame and room size.
- Compatibility: If using an adjustable base, check if the mattress is compatible.
Comparison of Our Top 5 Mattresses
Comfort & Support
Cooling Technology
Eco-Friendliness
Motion Isolation
Durability
Edge Support
Trial Period
Warranty
Customizability
Price Range
Website
Comfort & Support
Cooling Technology
Eco-Friendliness
Motion Isolation
Durability
Edge Support
Trial Period
Warranty
Customizability
Price Range
Website
Comfort & Support
Cooling Technology
Eco-Friendliness
Motion Isolation
Durability
Edge Support
Trial Period
Warranty
Customizability
Price Range
Website
Comfort & Support
Cooling Technology
Eco-Friendliness
Motion Isolation
Durability
Edge Support
Trial Period
Warranty
Customizability
Price Range
Website
Comfort & Support
Cooling Technology
Eco-Friendliness
Motion Isolation
Durability
Edge Support
Trial Period
Warranty
Customizability
Price Range
Website
How We Rate the Best Products: Our Methodology
The Key to Consumer-Driven Ratings Discovering the best products can be overwhelming, but we make it simple with our expert reviews and comprehensive rankings. Here’s how we ensure you’re getting the most accurate and reliable ratings:
Thorough Research
From understanding the ideal materials to analyzing innovative designs, we dig deep into the data to ensure the top product in each category meets diverse consumer needs.
Consumer Reviews
Real feedback matters. We analyze thousands of customer reviews, taking into account both positive and negative experiences to see which products consistently satisfy users.
Hands-On Testing
Our team of experts personally tests each top product, focusing on what consumers care about most—performance, durability, ease of use, and overall value.
Detailed Comparisons
From brand leaders to emerging competitors, we perform side-by-side comparisons of the best products in each category. This allows us to rank them based on the key criteria that matter to you.